Clear glass mug of banana pudding with caramel-colored syrup streaks, sliced banana, and tapioca pearls

Brown Sugar Banana Protein Pudding

Banana pudding meets brown sugar boba in this high-protein dessert. Make it the night before so the wafers soften while you sleep.

Makes one 32 oz tub, or 4 servings.

Watch the recipe

Jump to the method

Estimated macros

Whole tub: about 1,150 cal and 138 g protein.

Per serving (1/4 tub): about 290 cal and 34 g protein before pearls (pearls add about 50 to 100 cal).

What you need

Ingredients

  • 1 tub (32 oz)
  • 2 scoops
  • 1/4 to 1/3 cup
  • 4 tbsp
  • 1 large
  • About 16

How to make it

Method

  1. Mix the protein paste

    Whisk the whey with the milk, a splash at a time, until it forms a thick paste like frosting.

  2. Make the protein yogurt

    Scoop about 1 cup of Greek yogurt into a bowl and fold in the protein paste plus 2 tbsp brown sugar syrup.

  3. Sweeten the remaining yogurt

    Stir the remaining 2 tbsp brown sugar syrup into the rest of the yogurt.

  4. Stripe the glass

    Drizzle brown sugar syrup down the inside of the glass to make tiger stripes.

  5. Layer the pudding

    Layer plain yogurt, sliced banana, Nilla wafers, and protein yogurt, then repeat and finish with wafers on top.

  6. Chill overnight

    Chill overnight so the wafers soften and the pudding sets.

  7. Add the pearls

    Right before serving, top with warm tapioca pearls and one last drizzle of syrup.